Veteran Agri-Economist and Policy Expert Dr SS Johal questions freebees by Bhagwant Mann Govt
Babushahi Bureau
Chandigarh, June 20, 2026: Eminent agricultural economist and public policy expert Dr. S.S. Johal has sharply criticised the Punjab government's welfare measures, arguing that excessive subsidies and free schemes risk fostering dependency and undermining the spirit of self-reliance among Punjabis.
In remarks directed at Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Singh Mann, Dr. Johal said that while he shares a cordial personal relationship with the Chief Minister, he strongly disagrees with the government's approach to providing free services and commodities.
"Bhagwant Mann is dear to me and used to call me 'uncle'. That affection remains, but as Chief Minister he has adopted policies that I believe are harmful to Punjab's long-term interests," Dr. Johal said.
Questioning the state's welfare model, he argued that the provision of free electricity, water and other subsidised benefits has encouraged a culture of dependency rather than productivity.
"By giving away free water, electricity and other benefits, governments are gradually turning people into dependents. Punjabis have always been known for their hard work, self-respect and entrepreneurial spirit. These qualities should be strengthened, not weakened," he remarked.
In a sarcastic comment aimed at what he described as an expanding "freebies culture", Dr. Johal said that if the trend continues, the government might as well make alcohol free too and continue ruling indefinitely.
Using a literary reference, he warned that excessive dependence on state support could erode Punjab's social and economic vitality. "Such policies risk creating a society that loses its initiative and pride. In the long run, this could damage Punjab's image and future prospects," he said.
Dr. Johal's comments come amid an ongoing national debate over welfare schemes and so-called "freebies", with supporters arguing that such measures provide relief to struggling households, while critics contend that they place a heavy burden on state finances and discourage economic self-sufficiency.